Performance Reviews

Navigating Difficult Conversations: Tips for Giving Negative Feedback in a Performance Review

Giving negative feedback in a review is hard. How to stay specific, fair, and constructive without making it personal.
Published
October 2026
Table of Contents

Performance reviews can be difficult, especially when you have to give negative feedback to an employee. It's important to approach the conversation in a constructive way and to focus on the employee's behavior and not their character. Here are some suggestions for how to write concerning-but-fair review language.

  1. Be specific: Rather than making general statements about the employee's performance, provide specific examples of areas where they need improvement. This will help the employee understand what they need to work on and will also help you back up your points.
  2. Focus on the behavior, not the person: It's important to avoid making personal attacks or being critical of the employee's character. Instead, focus on the specific actions or behaviors that need improvement.
  3. Offer solutions: In addition to pointing out areas for improvement, it's helpful to offer suggestions for how the employee can address these issues. This could include training opportunities or additional resources.
  4. Keep an open mind: It's possible that the employee may have a different perspective on the situation. Be open to hearing their side and consider their suggestions for improvement.
  5. Follow up: After the performance review, make sure to follow up with the employee to see how they are progressing with the areas that need improvement. Set specific goals and checkpoints to track their progress, and offer additional support as needed. This will show the employee that you are invested in their development and that you are committed to helping them succeed.

‍

FAQ

How do you give negative feedback in a performance review?

Be specific, focus on behavior rather than character, and approach the conversation constructively.

How do you word concerning but fair review language?

Cite concrete, dated examples and describe their impact instead of generalizing — see effective performance review phrases.

What if the employee gets defensive?

Pause, listen, and return to specific examples rather than arguing; agree on a follow-up plan before ending the meeting.

Latest Posts
Performance Reviews

How to Turn Continuous Feedback Into a Performance Review

You've been collecting feedback all year. Here's how to turn it into a fair performance review without starting from a blank page.
Read post
Performance Reviews

How to Use Jira Tickets in Performance Reviews

How to use Jira tickets as evidence in performance reviews, which signals matter, and why velocity and ticket counts make a bad scorecard.
Read post
Performance Reviews

Performance Management Software That Integrates With Jira: What to Look For

Performance management software with Jira integration: what to look for, what tickets can't tell you, and what to ask before you buy.
Read post

Want performance reviews for you team, but without the hassle?
Try WorkStory now.

Performance review software that actually finishes on time